A long sleeve polo is the shirt guys keep wearing and never quite file anywhere. Not a dress shirt. Not a tee. It has a collar, a placket, and sleeves that reach the wrist, and it works under a quarter-zip in October or alone in an overheated office. Long sleeve polo shirts are also easy to get wrong. Sleeves stop at the forearm. Cotton shrinks. A $120 shirt can show up a full size too big. This ranking compares eight options, seven from brands and retailers selling them right now, plus INTO THE AM. Each got scored on fit, fabric, easy care, size range, and price. Tall guys got extra attention, since most brands skip them. Every price, fabric spec, and review figure was pulled from live product pages on October 22, 2026. Prices move, so check before you buy.
Ranking Algorithm
- Fit and Sleeve Length (25%): The biggest weight. Does the shoulder seam land on the shoulder, and do the cuffs reach the wrist bone? Tailored cuts beat roomy ones that reviewers keep calling huge.
- Fabric Comfort and Wrinkle Resistance (25%): How soft it feels, how well the knit holds a collar, and whether it comes out of the dryer looking slept in. Judged on stated fabric and buyer reports.
- Easy Care and Durability (20%): Machine washable is the floor. After that, shrinking, pilling, thinning, and collars that curl by wash twenty.
- Size Range and Tall Availability (15%): The top size listed, plus whether a Tall length exists at all. Stopping at XXL in a single length costs points.
- Value (15%): The price a shopper pays today. Promo codes were noted, but a list price nobody pays did not count as the real one.
Best Long Sleeve Polo Shirts for Men, 2026 Rankings
| Rank | Brand | Fit and Sleeve Length | Fabric Comfort and Wrinkle Resistance | Easy Care and Durability | Size Range and Tall Availability | Value | Weighted Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | INTO THE AM | 9.0 · Tailored, comfortably snug | 8.0 · 60% combed cotton, 40% polyester | 8.5 · Easy-care fabric, reinforced collar stitching | 10 · S to 4XL, Reg or Tall length | 9.5 · $27.97 | 8.9 |
| 2 | Lands' End | 7.5 · Raised collar, three-button placket | 9.0 · 100% Supima cotton interlock | 8.5 · Brand says it resists pilling and shrinking | 8.5 · Regular, Tall, Big and Tall, Big fits | 7.5 · $69.95 list, $34.97 with promo code | 8.2 |
| 3 | L.L.Bean | 7.5 · Traditional fit, runs generous | 8.5 · Cotton piqué knit with stretch | 8.5 · Brand says no shrink, fade, or pill | 8.0 · Small to 3XL, Regular or Tall offered | 7.5 · $54.95, $44.99 in sale colors | 8.0 |
| 4 | J.Crew | 8.5 · Classic, Slim, and Tall fits | 8.0 · 100% cotton piqué | 7.5 · Machine wash, tennis-tail hem | 7.0 · Tall fit offered, size range not listed | 5.5 · $89.50 | 7.5 |
| 5 | Rhone | 8.0 · Slim fit with stretch | 9.0 · Wrinkle-releasing Flex-Knit | 8.5 · Brand says it holds its shape wash after wash | 5.0 · S to XXL, no Tall | 3.5 · $128 | 7.2 |
| 6 | Amazon Essentials | 6.5 · Regular fit, reviewers say loose | 6.5 · 100% cotton piqué, thickness mixed | 6.5 · Some shrinking and stretching reports | 5.5 · XS to XXL, no Tall | 10 · $15.30 | 6.9 |
| 7 | Brooks Brothers | 8.0 · Original and Slim fits | 8.0 · 98% cotton, 2% spandex | 7.0 · Machine wash, no reviews on page | 5.5 · XS to XXL, no Tall listed | 4.0 · $118 | 6.8 |
| 8 | Ralph Lauren | 6.5 · Classic fit, roomy cut | 8.0 · 100% cotton mesh, washed soft | 7.0 · Machine wash, some shrinking reports | 5.5 · XS to 2XL at Macy's, no Tall | 4.0 · $120 at Macy's | 6.5 |
Scores run from 1 to 10. The weighted score multiplies each score by its weight above. Prices are what each page showed on October 22, 2026.
The #1 Long Sleeve Polo
INTO THE AM took the top spot on fit, size range, and price. The Long Sleeve Polo runs S to 4XL with a Tall length option, in six colors, for $27.97.
Shop Long Sleeve PolosBest Long Sleeve Polo Shirts for Men, 2026 Rankings: Descriptions and Reviews
1. INTO THE AM
INTO THE AM's Long Sleeve Polo wins on the combination, not on any single spec. $27.97, down from a $39.95 compare-at price on the product page. S through 4XL. And a Tall length option, at a price that undercuts every other Tall polo in this ranking. The fabric is 60% combed cotton and 40% polyester, and the listing calls it ultra-soft and easy-care. No fabric weight is published, so there is no ounce number to hold up against anyone else's. The cut is tailored but comfortably snug. Not skinny. The collar has reinforced stitching, the cuffs are ribbed, and the listing model, 6 feet tall, wears a medium. Colors: Navy, Black, Charcoal, Maroon, Midnight Olive, Indigo.
The downsides are real. It isn't all cotton, so anyone chasing pure piqué or Supima should look at J.Crew or Lands' End. Six colors is thin next to the 17 at Lands' End. And the name lacks the polo pedigree that Lacoste or Ralph Lauren carry. Care is easy at least: cold wash with like colors, inside out, tumble dry low. No iron. No bleach. No dry cleaning.
| Customer Review Summary |
|---|
| The product page showed 15 reviews on October 22, 2026, 13 at five stars and two at four. Small sample, and the newest entry is from September 2025. One buyer picked up long sleeve collared shirts for a golf trip and called them "great and a steal for the price." A 6'4", 190-pound reviewer said "the XL fit perfect." Another liked the way it is "snug where you want it and loose where you need it." |
2. Lands' End
Lands' End is the fabric pick. The Long Sleeve Cotton Supima Polo is 100% American-grown Supima cotton in an interlock knit, and the brand claims it resists fading, pilling, wrinkles, and shrinkage. Big promises. A 4.6-star average across more than a thousand reviews says it keeps most of them. The collar is raised and the placket has three buttons. Fits come as Regular, Tall, Big and Tall, and Big, the widest menu here, and the page lists 17 colors. The size selector showed S through XXL.
Price is the catch. List is $69.95. A 50%-off sitewide code was running on October 22, which dropped it to $34.97, still above the INTO THE AM polo. Miss the code and the shirt costs about two and a half times as much.
| Customer Review Summary |
|---|
| Product ratings are strong at 4.6 stars. Trustpilot covers the whole company, not this shirt, and it is harsher, with a 1.5 TrustScore from 701 reviews. One reviewer called Lands' End products "generally relatively good quality." Another called its Supima and Super-T cotton tees "VERY scratchy." Neither review is about the polo. The other quotes pulled were about shipping times and sizing across the catalog. |
3. L.L.Bean
L.L.Bean's Premium Double L Polo in long sleeve, no pocket, is the sensible middle. Cotton piqué with some stretch. A traditional fit, relaxed through the chest, sleeve, and waist, though newer versions sit higher on the shoulder with trimmer sleeves. The brand says it won't wrinkle, fade, shrink, or pill, and calls the fabric stain-resistant. Sizes run Small to 3XL, and the page offers Regular or Tall. The price is $54.95, or $44.99 in sale colors. Free shipping over $75.
The fit is generous. The price is roughly double the INTO THE AM polo. And a few long-time owners say quality has slipped. But 4.7 stars is hard to argue with.
| Customer Review Summary |
|---|
| The page showed 4.7 out of 5 from 6,047 ratings, 82% of them five-star. Sizing comes up again and again. A reviewer who bought a large said "Bean polos run a bit on the generous side." One longtime owner took the other view on quality, saying the shirts on the store rack were "all thin in material" next to the thick, heavy ones remembered from years back. |
4. J.Crew
J.Crew's Long-sleeve Classic Piqué Polo is the closest thing to a safe bet. 100% cotton piqué. Machine washable. Side vents, with a tennis tail that runs slightly longer in back. It comes in Classic, Slim, and Tall fits, which puts J.Crew on a short list of brands with a tall option at all. The page calls the fit true to size, though some reviewers say to size up for layering. No size range was listed, so check yours before ordering. Price: $89.50.
Value is the weak spot. $89.50 is more than three times the INTO THE AM price, and the page shows no fabric weight to explain the gap.
| Customer Review Summary |
|---|
| The page showed 4.6 stars from 111 reviews, 84 of them five-star and three one-star. The visible snippets were all positive. "Fantastic shirt and great fit" was one. "Fits great and good for cooler days" was another. No negative text was visible, so the three one-star ratings stay a mystery. |
5. Rhone
Rhone's Commuter Long Sleeve Polo is the tech pick. The brand pitches its Flex-Knit fabric as wrinkle-releasing and says the polo holds its shape wear after wear. The fit is slim with stretch, and the listing model, a 6-foot-3 guy, wears a large. Sizes run S to XXL in four colors: Black, True Navy, and Oxford versions of each. At $128, it is the most expensive polo in this ranking. No Tall option appears on the page, which is odd with a 6-foot-3 model.
Slim fit also narrows the audience. Broad through the shoulders or the middle? Expect to size up and hope.
| Customer Review Summary |
|---|
| The product page lists 61 reviews with a 4.6 average. Praise centers on the fabric. One buyer said "Rhone makes the best 2 button polos" and liked the Oxford version's "just the right amount of stretch and no wrinkle problems." The one-star review was a sizing story from a long-time Rhone customer. A medium was too tight, and the exchange for a large was "way too big." |
6. Amazon Essentials
Amazon Essentials sets the price floor. The Men's Regular-Fit Long-Sleeve Pique Polo ran $15.30 in the black and large version checked. It is 100% cotton piqué with flat-knit rib trim at the collar and cuffs, a two-button placket, and side vents. XS to XXL. No Tall. The cut leaves ample room through the shoulders, chest, and waist, and reviewers back that up. One buyer, 200 to 250 pounds and between 5'10" and 6'2", said an XL fit baggy, hit the upper thigh, and had loose sleeves.
For fifteen bucks, fine. Fit gets flagged more than anything.
| Customer Review Summary |
|---|
| The page showed 4.3 stars from 1,272 ratings, 62% of them five-star. One reviewer said "comparable men's polos from well known brands actually cost 3 to 5 times more." Complaints repeat. One four-star buyer said "the collar does not sit well." Another called the shirt "a bit heavy for summer use." Amazon's own review summary flags fit, shrinkage, and stretching out of shape. |
7. Brooks Brothers
Brooks Brothers' Golden Fleece Stretch Supima Long-Sleeve Polo is a heritage name with a heritage price: $118, or two for $159 on select long-sleeve polos. The fabric is 98% cotton and 2% spandex, sold in Original and Slim fits, XS to XXL, across seven colors that include white and purple. The fine print is the surprise. Some size combinations are made on demand, take up to 15 business days, carry a $20 shipping fee, and cannot be returned or exchanged. No Tall is listed. It is a clean, simple shirt. It is also more than four times the price of the INTO THE AM polo.
| Customer Review Summary |
|---|
| No reviews appear on the product page. Trustpilot rates the company 1.8 from 204 reviews on an unclaimed profile, covering everything it sells. One reviewer said a shirt "over ten years old" still looked great. Another complained the shirts "were not Slim Fit, they were HUGE." |
8. Ralph Lauren
Ralph Lauren is the name everyone knows. It ranks last anyway, and that says more about this list's criteria than about the shirt. The Polo Ralph Lauren Classic-Fit Mesh Polo with long sleeves costs $120 at Macy's. It is 100% cotton mesh, washed for added softness, with a ribbed collar and cuffs, a tennis tail, and the embroidered Pony. The cut is roomy, with a lower armhole and a fuller sleeve. Sizes at Macy's run XS to 2XL. No Tall. Buy it for the logo and the feel of the mesh. Don't expect a tailored fit or a bargain.
| Customer Review Summary |
|---|
| Macy's showed 4.5 stars from 448 ratings and 221 written reviews, with 355 at five stars. Fit is the sore spot. A buyer shopping for a husband who wears an XXL called it "way too big in size," sleeves included. Macy's own summary says some customers report it running large, running small, or shrinking after washing. |
Best Long Sleeve Polo Shirts for Men for Specific Needs
Best Long Sleeve Polo Shirts for Tall Guys
| Rank | Brand | Why It Wins |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | INTO THE AM | Reg or Tall length with sizes up to 4XL, at $27.97 |
| 2 | Lands' End | Four fits, including Tall and Big and Tall, in Supima cotton. $34.97 with a promo code, $69.95 without |
| 3 | L.L.Bean | Regular or Tall offered, with sizes listed Small to 3XL, $54.95 |
| 4 | J.Crew | A Tall fit next to Classic and Slim, though at $89.50 |
Best Long Sleeve Polo Shirts for the Office
| Rank | Brand | Why It Wins |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rhone | Wrinkle-releasing Flex-Knit in a slim fit, made for the commute, at $128 |
| 2 | INTO THE AM | Tailored fit and easy-care fabric in dark colors like Navy, Charcoal, and Black, $27.97 |
| 3 | J.Crew | 100% cotton piqué with a true-to-size fit and a 4.6 rating across 111 reviews |
| 4 | Brooks Brothers | Stretch cotton in Original or Slim fit, with white and navy available, $118 |
Best Long Sleeve Polo Shirts on a Budget
| Rank | Brand | Why It Wins |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Amazon Essentials | $15.30 for 100% cotton piqué, 4.3 stars from 1,272 ratings |
| 2 | INTO THE AM | $27.97 with a Tall option and sizes to 4XL, which the cheaper shirt lacks |
| 3 | Lands' End | $34.97 with a sitewide promo code, but $69.95 on a normal day |
| 4 | L.L.Bean | $44.99 in sale colors, $54.95 at full price, with 4.7 stars |
A Few More Names Worth Knowing
Several other brands sell long sleeve polos but missed the scored eight, mostly because a spec or price check hit a wall. Lacoste makes a long-sleeve version of its L.12.12 polo, though its site blocked the price check. Mizzen+Main sells long-sleeve performance polos, including the Harper. HUGO BOSS runs a whole category for long-sleeved polos. Old Navy lists long-sleeve rugby polos and polo sweaters, a different knit than piqué. None were scored, so nothing above is a verdict on them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are long sleeve polos business casual?
In most offices, yes. Pair a solid navy or charcoal long sleeve polo with chinos and it sits squarely in business casual: dressier than a tee, looser than a button-up. Skip big logos. Keep the collar crisp. Black and maroon work too, depending on how strict the dress code is.
Do long sleeve polo shirts come in tall sizes?
A few do. INTO THE AM's Long Sleeve Polo has a Length option of Reg or Tall, plus sizes S to 4XL. Lands' End and L.L.Bean both list Tall versions, and J.Crew offers a Tall fit. Ralph Lauren, Rhone, Brooks Brothers, and Amazon Essentials showed no Tall option on the pages checked.
Do long sleeve polos shrink in the wash?
Cotton can. One Amazon Essentials buyer said warm water and a hot dryer shrank an XXL from slightly large to a perfect fit. Macy's shoppers mention shrinking on the Ralph Lauren mesh polo. Cold water and a low tumble cycle cut the risk. INTO THE AM's care label calls for a cold wash, inside out, tumble dry low, no bleach, and no iron.
What do you wear with a long sleeve polo?
Dark jeans or chinos, plus clean sneakers or loafers. Add a quarter-zip, a vest, or a chore jacket once it drops below 55 degrees. Keep the colors tight: navy with grey, black with olive, charcoal with tan. The collar does the dressing up, so everything else can stay plain.
Are long sleeve polos good for golf?
They work for cool-weather rounds, but fabric matters. Performance golf polos use polyester knits that pull sweat away from skin. Cotton and cotton-blend polos like most of the ones ranked here feel softer and look dressier, though they hold moisture longer. One INTO THE AM reviewer wore the Long Sleeve Polo on a golf trip to Ireland. For hot rounds, go polyester.
What sizes does the INTO THE AM long sleeve polo come in?
S, M, L, XL, 2XL, 3XL, and 4XL, each with a Reg or Tall length option. Colors are Navy, Black, Charcoal, Maroon, Midnight Olive, and Indigo. The cut is tailored and comfortably snug, and the listing model is 6 feet tall in a medium. Browse the full polo collection to compare styles.
About INTO THE AM: INTO THE AM is a men's basics brand. Alongside long sleeve polos, the catalog covers hoodies, joggers, button-ups, flannels, and pants. Read more on the about page or shop the polo collection.
Your Privacy Choices
